Our Blogs

Understanding Your Claim

Dog bites are more than just a surface injury; they can be profoundly traumatic—physically, emotionally, and financially. The immediate chaos often gives way to daunting questions about how you will pay for hospital visits, plastic surgery, lost work time, and emotional counseling. If you or a loved one has been bitten, you absolutely have rights, and understanding the legal pathways available is your first step toward recovery.

The process of seeking justice often boils down to one key question: Are you pursuing an insurance claim or a full lawsuit? An insurance claim is typically a negotiation with the dog owner’s insurance company (usually their homeowner’s policy) to settle before filing a court document. A full lawsuit is a formal court action required when liability is disputed, the insurance company refuses to pay fairly, or the injuries are severe.

This guide will walk you through the entire process, from the moments immediately following the bite to navigating complex liability rules and understanding the financial risks of litigation. As this is for informational purposes, please consult an attorney in your state for specific legal advice.

Immediate Post-Bite Checklist (Pre-Litigation)

The actions you take in the hours and days following an attack are crucial and will form the foundation of any future claim or lawsuit.

• Medical Priority: Documentation is Evidence. Your first priority is immediate medical care to prevent infection (which is common and severe in bite wounds) and treat the trauma. You must document everything. Take dated, high-resolution photographs of your wounds immediately after the incident, after initial cleaning, and throughout the healing process. Follow your doctor’s orders precisely; failing to do so can be used by the defense to argue you did not mitigate your damages. Keep every single bill, co-pay receipt, and record of lost work time.
• Gather Evidence: The Who, What, and Where. Do your best to secure the owner’s information, including their full name, address, and, if possible, their homeowner’s insurance details. Get the dog’s breed, name, and vaccination history. Crucially, find and record the contact information for any witnesses. An impartial witness statement is often the single most powerful piece of evidence, as it provides an objective account of the attack. Finally, take detailed notes on the attack—where you were, what the dog was doing, and what the owner said (or failed to do) immediately before and after the incident.
• Report the Bite: Establishing an Official Record. You must file an official report with local Animal Control or the police immediately. This report creates an objective, third-party record of the event. If the animal is deemed “dangerous” or “vicious” in the official report, it can be essential evidence in establishing the owner’s liability later on.

Establishing Liability: The Three Legal Pillars

Dog bite laws vary dramatically by state, but nearly every claim hinges on one of three legal concepts:

• Strict Liability (The Gold Standard): In states with strict liability laws (like California, Michigan, and Pennsylvania), the owner is automatically held responsible for your injuries, regardless of whether they knew the dog had aggressive tendencies. You only need to prove two things: that the defendant owned the dog and that the dog bit you while you were lawfully on the property. This rule is often considered the most favorable for the victim.
• The One-Bite Rule (Owner Knowledge is Key): In states adhering to the traditional “one-bite rule,” you must prove the owner knew (or should have known) the dog was dangerous or had exhibited prior aggression. Essentially, the owner gets a “free pass” for the first incident. To defeat this, your attorney will try to find evidence of past behavior, such as prior complaints filed with Animal Control, warnings given to neighbors, or signs posted by the owner (like “Beware of Dog”).
• Negligence (Failure to Exercise Care): This is the fallback rule. It argues that the owner failed to act as a reasonable person would to control their animal, and that failure led directly to your injury. Examples of negligence include allowing a dog to roam off-leash in violation of local ordinances, knowingly ignoring a broken fence, or lack of warnings.

The Role of Insurance: Where the Money Comes From

When you sue a dog owner, you are rarely trying to seize their personal property. Instead, you are typically seeking recovery from their insurance company.

• Homeowner’s/Renter’s Insurance: The Primary Source of Recovery. In most successful dog bite cases, the settlement is paid out of the owner’s liability coverage within their homeowner’s or renter’s insurance policy. The insurance company hires the defense attorney, manages the legal defense, and ultimately pays the settlement (up to the policy limits). How the insurance company values the claim is based on documented evidence: your medical bills, lost wages, and the severity of the permanent physical and emotional injuries.
• Crucial Detail: Understanding the Dog Bite Liability Limits. Standard homeowner’s policies often have liability limits of $100,000 to $300,000. If your catastrophic injuries (such as major facial disfigurement requiring multiple surgeries) exceed that limit, a full lawsuit may be necessary to pursue the owner’s personal assets (like equity in their home). Your attorney will evaluate the owner’s net worth to determine if this is a financially viable path.
• The Uninsured Owner and Breed Exclusions. If the owner has no insurance, or if their policy specifically excludes coverage for the breed of dog that bit you (common for Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, and other breeds), the case becomes significantly more complex. Unless the owner has substantial personal wealth, pursuing a lawsuit may be financially impractical, as you cannot recover money that does not exist.

Navigating the Legal Process

If the initial insurance negotiation fails, or if your injuries are severe, your attorney will likely recommend filing a formal lawsuit.

• The Consultation and Contingency Fee: The Hidden Cost. Most personal injury attorneys operate on a contingency fee basis—they only get paid if they win the case. The fee typically ranges from 33% to 40% of the final settlement or verdict. However, there is a hidden cost you must understand: case costs. These are the expenses necessary to run the lawsuit (filing fees, court reporter fees, expert witness fees, postage, etc.). While the attorney can advance these costs, the client is responsible for paying them back, regardless of whether the case is won or lost. Make sure to clarify this arrangement during your initial consultation.
• The Statute of Limitations: The Clock Is Ticking. Every state has a Statute of Limitations (SOL), which is a non-negotiable deadline for filing a lawsuit after an injury. This period is typically between one and six years, and it varies depending on the state and the age of the victim. If you miss this deadline, your case is permanently dismissed.
• The Lawsuit Stages (Simplified):
  1. Filing the Complaint: The formal court document is filed, and the owner is officially served, beginning the legal action.
  2. Discovery: This is the evidence-gathering phase. Both sides exchange information through written questions (Interrogatories), requests for documents (medical and financial records), and sworn, recorded interviews (Depositions). This phase often lasts six months to a year.
  3. Mediation/Settlement Negotiation: Over 95% of all civil lawsuits resolve before trial. A neutral third-party mediator works with both sides to find a compromise.
  4. Trial: If mediation fails, the case proceeds to a jury trial. This is expensive, emotionally draining, and unpredictable.

What the Defense Will Argue (Countering the Owner’s Claims)

The dog owner’s attorney is paid to minimize their client’s liability. They will actively seek to shift blame to the victim using several key defenses:

• Provocation: Claiming the victim teased, taunted, or physically harmed the dog, causing the reaction.
• Trespassing/Unlawful Entry: Arguing the victim was not lawfully on the property and therefore forfeited their right to safety.
• Comparative/Contributory Negligence: Claiming the victim was partially at fault 

Calculating Damages (What is Your Case Worth?)

Your total compensation is divided into two primary categories:

• Economic Damages: These are easily calculated losses, proven by receipts and documentation: medical bills, rehabilitation costs, lost wages, and future loss of earning capacity.
• Non-Economic Damages: These are subjective and account for the real, long-term impact of the injury: physical pain, emotional suffering, permanent scarring, disfigurement, and the loss of enjoyment of life. This is where an experienced lawyer’s negotiation skills are crucial.
• Punitive Damages: These are rarely awarded and are reserved for cases where the owner has acted with extreme recklessness or malice 

What to Do Next

Navigating a dog bite lawsuit requires diligence, patience, and the guidance of a professional. The single most important factors in your success are the quality of your documentation and the speed of your action. By understanding the legal pillars of liability, the reality of insurance limits, and the procedural phases of a lawsuit, you are empowered to have a productive first consultation with an attorney. 

Get a free legal consultation today from an expert legal attorney – contact us for one now.